Refractions

Refractions

Refractive Communications  //  A matter of message perspective and customer communications.

Mar 4 / 8:19pm

A Customer is Not a Process

Howarthoboe2

Come on … say it with me.

“A customer is not a process.”

Part 1

My oldest daughter plays the oboe, and plays it quite well. It was time for us to buy her “a good one” with full conservatory fingering, so we went (an hour’s drive) to the largest in-stock music instrument inventory store in the world: Chuck Levin’s Washington Music Center, a crammed-full, old fashioned-styled, complete-with-original-wooden-cashier-cage, family-run establishment.

Now here’s where it gets real interesting …

After doing all the right things (with attentive, personal service), we selected a handmade, wooden Howarth oboe and went to pay for it. Novel as it may sound, we had saved up for this moment and I wrote a check from our special-purchase savings account. The salesclerk in her wooden cashier’s castle dutifully processed the check, processed it again, and then somberly handed it back to me with a little slip of paper. “Telecheck could not validate your check. Call them on the phone there and see what’s holding it up.”

The telephone conversation went well enough at first: yep, received check request; yes, you have sufficient funds in the account; validated, excellent credit history; okay, updated and confirmed this info in my system file. Great! I asked for whatever approval code I needed to hand the patient folks here at the music store, and I’d be on my way.

--- Can’t do that. Not enough account activity.

--- But this is our special savings account for the rare, special purchase; not much activity.

--- No can do. Not enough transaction activity.

The conversation went downhill in a rush after that.

I was a process, not a customer---not even a customer-once-removed on behalf of the music store. And I couldn’t get him to see it.

Even if Telecheck did not empower him to approve the transaction, he should have had the customer-service-sense to pass me on to a superior who did. Nope. No way. No how.

The only solution he could offer was for me to write numerous checks of small amounts over the next seven days, and then try the larger purchase again.

I had an empty checkbox next to my name in their heartless automated system and there was nothing I could do---or that he would do---to fix it.

There in the music store, I started storyboarding a Telecheck music video in the fine tradition of United Breaks Guitars.

Part 2

After re-cradling the receiver (have you slammed down a phone in the last 11 years? … MUCH more satisfying than pushing an Off button), I returned to the old-fashioned, wooden cashier cage and summarized for the lady inside the one point or two that she might not have overheard of my emphatic telephone discussion.

She looked at me for a moment and my daughter cradling the almost-hers oboe, and said, “Let me see that check. I’ll be right back.” She soon returned and said, “No problem. May I see your driver’s license?”

Less than 10 minutes later, my daughter and I walked out into the sunshine with her new oboe ... proud to be valued customers of Chuck Levin’s Washington Music Store.

I know we are … I’m writing this post, and my daughter has the oboe and an unexpected, free Washington Music Store T-shirt that she wore to school the next day.

A customer is not a process; he or she is an opportunity. Try delighting one, and see what happens.

 

Filed under  //  customers  

Comments (0)

Mar 3 / 12:34am

You're too much. Really.

Stuffed
 
You're forcing too much on your customers. It's not working, think about it ...

You, sandwich restaurant. You have 12 different garnishes (does anyone say "garnishes" anymore?); count them ... 12. And then you have eight choices for bread, seven different meats, grilled/cold/toasted/nuked/open-faced/regular wrap/lettuce-wrap, fries: string/wrinkle/curly/hand-cut/wedgies/no-salt/extra-salt/spicy/plain, small drink/medium/large/extra large/bucket, carry-in/carry-out, and the final harassment ... paper or plastic?

I no longer know what having it my way means ... my way has way more options than my way ever had before.

Do you differentiate by expanding your core product line with custom options ... just like everyone else?

Quick, which fast food restaurant serves fried chicken sandwiches? Kentucky Fried Chicken? Hardy's? Wendy's? McDonald's? Burger King? Arby's?

Quick, which fast food restaurant serves roast beef sandwiches? Arby's? Burger King? McDonald's? Wendy's? Hardy's? Kentucky Fried Chicken?

What's your core value? What's your core skill? Can you easily find them in your product offering?

Do what you do, and do that service or product better than anybody else. Make something unforgettable, and don't dilute it.

There's nothing memorable in being everything.

Filed under  //  customers  

Comments (0)

May 4 / 6:18am

Wi-Fi Bandit Caught Again

Att12059

 

This saga begins with me standing at a Starbucks counter repeating in an incredulous voice what the server had just told me, “The Wi-Fi isn’t free? I have to buy a Starbucks card first?” Nodding sympathetically with a wry smile, she agreed and then said in a conspiratorial whisper, “But it’s free down the street at Panera Bread.”

 

I was in the midst of a 238-mile journey home on a Friday night at 8:20 PM with a pending online task to complete, but I left.


I was willing to pay for coffee, and maybe a pastry, and possibly something else … but I was not going to pay for Wi-Fi. It’s like having to pay for napkins: “Napkins available for free with your $15 Starbucks card purchase.


I drove down the street to Panera Bread, parked, shouldered my laptop case and hurried to the entrance. A colorful sign on the glass entry door caught my eye, “Free Wi-fi.” I bought coffee and a chocolate pastry, and began working. Just before the 9 PM closing time, I completed and emailed the revised file to my coworker across the country.

  

From the customer experience perspective, Panera Bread's free Wi-Fi was a true customer benefit: easy, free, non-intrusive. Starbucks' misguided attempt to force customer "loyalty" and stickiness derailed a potential customer into the welcoming arms of a competitor. I used to think, "Coffee = Starbucks." But now I've been taught, "Coffee = Panera Bread (+ Wi-Fi + food)." For a company centered on serving coffee, Starbucks now has nothing left in the equation to draw me in the doors again.


A few days later, I was traveling again and needed some coffee. I drove into a shopping center, past Starbucks and into an open parking space in front of Panera Bread. Shouldering my laptop case, I pushed in past the cheerful “Free Wi-Fi” sign on the door, ordered a coffee, a pastry and a sourdough soup bowl lunch, and clicked through the latest online commentary as I ate.

 

Caught again.

 

Filed under  //  customers  

Comments (0)

Feb 11 / 2:54pm

More Than Just Woodsmoke

Beans
If you’ve ever enjoyed ash-dusted pancakes, innocently inquired after a left-handed smoke bender, and deftly tied a hatchet knot, then you and I have something in common. The 100th anniversary of the Boy Scouts of America started me thinking about the life skills I gained growing up in this intentional youth-building program.

Back then, I just understood Boy Scouting as a merry band of woodsmoke-soaked brothers taking on the wilderness. Little did I realize then that along the way I was being infused with marketable skills and values that serve me well today. Here are just a few, along with a couple of touchstone memories:

Leadership - Ready? Here’s your team of 8 boys, ages 11 to 17, some interested, some apathetic, some skilled, some intentionally ignorant, some fresh from the apron strings. Your task is to mold them into a competitive team, challenge them with stretch responsibilities, teach them new skills, push them to catch that second wind, assuage their bogeyman fears, build camaraderie, endure the “remember when” tent-drenching lightening storms, and encourage leadership. One other thing ... you’re a Patrol Member, not the Leader.

Perseverance - A compass-guided, backcountry orienteering course is a great way to carefully get lost. With a topographic map, compass coordinates and a compass in hand, my two compatriots and I, along with a lips-sealed adult leader, headed off on a deep woods bearing to track down the brightly-colored clues marking each point on the course. We plotted and measured and sighted and trail-blazed all over those woods, but kept at it. We had clearly defined goals, we had the skills (barely), and we knew there was a way to accomplish the task. And we did. Three hours late, but we did. Even more remarkable, the leader tramped silently along with us and let us work it out ourselves, responding only twice the entire outing. I try to remember that patient soul when working with engaged, but novice, team members and my children.

Creativity - Your backpack shoulder strap just broke 21 miles into a 50-miler hike; fasten a new strap of braided rope and a whittled peg to secure it on your packframe. Need to dry soaked clothing at nightfall; fashion drying rack from sturdy branch embedded upright fireside. Buddy forgot pans; cook beans in cans. Buddy forgot hamburger meat; savor beans and eat his portion of dessert. I expect on any given weekend in this country, domesticated, coddled boys learn they can count on themselves and their Scout campmates to come through with a great idea.

Perspective - After a long day of canoeing in pursuit of another coveted 50-miler patch, we finally arrived at our intended riverside campsite to discover an occupying force of cows bedded down for the night. Too tired to argue, we retreated to a small, tree-covered island a little further downstream, set up quick camp, ate a cold meal, sacked out, and woke up shortly after midnight with water creeping in our tents from the upstream dam unexpectedly opening its floodgates. We tossed our soggy gear into the floating, but tied, canoes and took to the branches. Our treed Scoutmaster framed it as another challenge that couldn’t beat us, and our night hanging from the trees became an exciting, memorable experience instead of a frustrating obstacle.

Discerning Palate - When camping, food was what you made it---literally: pot-charred chili, ash-dusted pancakes, soapy scrambled eggs. If I could discern it was edible, I ate it. Don’t sweat the small annoyances; they’re small and fleeting unless you nurture them. That doesn’t mean you helplessly suffer, though. I started bringing a Plan B stash of little Granny Smith apples for cinnamon campfire-baked apples. Delicious.

As a youth, my family moved every three years. And every three years I was welcomed into a new band of boys enjoying the Scouting program, testing themselves, and most ending up as capable young men. 

What a concept.

Filed under  //  leadership  

Comments (0)

Jan 26 / 10:39am

The Right Knot Improves Customer Service

Shoestrings

I discovered a better way to serve my customers … all because I just learned how to tie my shoes.

This is in no way a poor reflection on my mother or maternal grandmother, who taught me as a young child how to tie the shoestring knot using a big ribbon around the neck of a 4-foot-long stuffed toy tiger. This is a reflection of a good-enough process providing sufficient results with easy-to-correct deviations. I never thought twice about tying my shoes … until a trustworthy source recently asked a fundamental question:

Are you tying your shoes the right way?

Of course, I am. Aren't I? My shoestring knot has two loops of near equal size, the shoestring ends (aglets) do not drag the ground, my shoes stay on my feet, and I only occasionally have to re-tie a loose knot.

Good enough.

But Runners World brings up the point that there is a right knot: it stays tight and many of us are tying the correct knot (a reef knot) on one shoe, but not the other. That’s me; how about you?

Now that I know the difference and I have bought-in to the benefit, basic though it may be, I’m relearning how to tie my left shoe (one of my 3 Words in action: Notebook). Six Sigma process improvement folks call this DMAIC: Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control. I’m in the Improve stage and finding it surprisingly difficult to alter my habit, but now my deliberately tied shoestrings are matching examples of beauty and performance (not like the pre-insight image above).

This got me wondering about possible good-enough habits in the way I process work, in the way I work with others, and in how my team conducts business. I took a thoughtful look at the everyday things I never thought twice about, and found that I should. A tweak here and change there would achieve an even better experience for my customers and me.

Have you intentionally thought about the processes you initiate or manage: the way you manage your email interactions, engage in personal discussions, address challenging situations?

Many years ago my Psyc 101 professor started the year by wordlessly projecting this statement on the screen for 10 seconds, “You have every right to be who you are, but no right to stay that way.” Now I’m thinking about how that statement applies to how I do things.

I found ways to improve. What did you find?
Filed under  //  leadership  

Comments (0)

Jan 19 / 12:17pm

Solving the Wrought Iron Rat's Nest

Clef

I like puzzles. Especially, a “tavern puzzle” crafted of wrought iron twisted and bent upon itself, and then intertwined with another piece. The goal is simple: Extract the one piece from the other. It’s the “doing” that’s perceived as daunting and I’ve had friends wave off even trying to solve such a complicated-looking conundrum.

In just the same way, I’ve seen very capable managers dodge leadership and project challenges because the doing looks too tough, or too unusual, or too far afield from what they’ve done before. Or else they rattle the situation around a bit to see if it will solve itself and then, if it doesn’t, confirm the situation as intractable and cobble together a work-around.

The key to the puzzle is a position of perception: There is a solution.

For example, I KNOW this cantankerous, obstinate metal ring will untangle from this wrought iron rat’s nest. I know there is some way to get turf-sensitive Department A and belligerent Department B to cooperatively achieve this market-changing goal.

I just don’t know how … yet.

If you look closely at my tavern puzzles, you’ll notice shiny spots in the crooks and bends where I time and again slid that metal ring along the wrought iron trying one idea after another; winnowing down the possibilities. There is a solution, usually something unexpected, unusual and, before now, untried.

Did you notice, though, that once you solve the challenge, you can much more easily do so again and again and again, even where others still cannot? A career skill differentiator. What challenge have you solved into a skill?

In my tavern puzzle collection is one called “The Treble Clef.” I worked that puzzle for days, trying this and that to no avail, until I finally solved it. “Check.” I knew how to solve that puzzle … and now I’m told “Treble Clef” has two solutions. 

Interesting. 

I wonder what happens if I go around this way …
Filed under  //  leadership  

Comments (0)

Jan 5 / 6:33pm

GPS. Architect. Notebook. 2010.

3words

I am not a natural list-maker. I am not even a natural list-checker to a list I did happen to draft into existence. Therefore, I am a poster child New Year’s resolution-maker in the time-honored tradition of make’ em and miss ‘em, which is fine unless I really want to achieve certain goals in the coming year.

So, if not a list of goals, what then to bring about the new me in 2010?

My natural state is a creative, big picture strategic thinker, quickly seeing connections, opportunities and possibilities in nearly all situations … and now I see my goals for 2010 coalescing around Chris Brogan’s “3 Words for 2010” approach.

Chris uses three words to guide his actions and the projects he takes on throughout the year. As he says, “… what I’m trying to do with the words is come up with something that would take more than a sentence to describe, but that when you think about it, the ideas explode out to fill your head with thoughts of how you might want to conduct yourself.”

Just three words: Got it.

No long list: Excellent.

Big picture thinking: Naturally.

After much pondering and, yes, a LIST of thoughts and ideas, I brewed it down to these three words that have meaning and direction for me in 2010:

1. GPS (God-Positioning System) – On track, attentive and in motion

2. Architect – Build up ideas, build up people, build up situations

3. Notebook – Note what I can learn from others, draft creative ideas in the margins

For another Three Words example, see Cheryl’s.

This’ll be an interesting year for me. I can tell already. A year of changes and achievements in three-part harmony. 

Naturally.
Filed under  //  ideas  

Comments (0)

Jan 4 / 8:21am

They Got It Wrong, Daddy

Collar

My youngest daughter sparked some thoughts on team management Sunday morning. She walked up to me in the dress she picked out and said, “They got it wrong, Daddy.”

Apparently after careful consideration, she intentionally put the dress on backwards. In her 8-year-old wisdom and opinion, she felt the dress looked better that way. It didn’t matter to her that a well-known brand, its century of experience, its bevy of educated designers and its well-established manufacturing processes clearly marked the back of the dress with the fancy tag now residing under her chin. She tried the dress on backwards, liked the result and came to me with her idea.

Can your team confidently come to you with your product on backwards in an off-label application that’s obviously not the way we do it around here? How would you respond if they did?

I like creative ideas. I encourage disruptive brainstorming. I’d rather back a crazy idea down to a brilliant idea than try to process-build up to one.

But do you, the leader, allow it? Have you given your team permission to generate wild ideas? Are you willing to consider them?

An open-door policy does little good with a closed mind sitting at the desk.

My daughter and I carefully considered her idea. We looked at how the dress fit, how it felt when she sat down and how the bows tied. After testing her idea, we agreed that the dress worked best with the tag in the back.

But, with what she knows now about testing her opinion, if I hear “They got it wrong, Daddy” again, I bet she walks out the front door wearing her dress backwards.

Filed under  //  ideas   leadership  

Comments (0)

Dec 14 / 11:11am

Fitness Center Unfit for Business

Oobsign

A friend mentioned that he’ll probably drop his fitness center membership this month to save money. He enjoys the new facility and programs, though he only uses the workout room. Apparently, other customers are feeling the financial pinch, too, so the facility is in a budget crunch … and what does the fitness center plan on doing about it?

They will raise the fee on the remaining members as of January 2010. Should we start painting the Out of Business sign now? Will the paint have time to dry before hanging it?

Unfortunately, this everyday circle-the-wagons business response misses the opportunity for creative customer engagement and retention … and growth.

What if, instead of raising the single, comprehensive membership fee, the fitness center broke the fee structure into three levels, each with greater degrees of access to facilities?

What if the inexpensive basic package allowed access to just one program … say, the workout room … and those customers had a black rubbery wristband that allowed them access to the workout room. Those signed up for swimming had a blue wristband.  Mid-level access (and price point) is a bundled package with its own, single distinguishing wristband. The premium level has the ultimate colored wristband.

What if the fitness facility staff came up with an even better approach than this one to segment their products?

Now their customers have lower barriers to entry, more purchase options, and, perhaps, a visible status incentive to increase their membership levels.

Never allow “Never done that before” to define your customer service. 

Always default to “What if …”
Filed under  //  customers  

Comments (0)

Dec 12 / 7:10am

Help Opportunity Knock

Opportunityknocks

My 20-something cousin just returned Stateside from serving in the Peace Corps in Ukraine and Ghana. She's preparing to kick off her DC job search for an international policy position, and asked me for suggestions from my own recession-sparked career change.

Here's the gist of the conversation:

1. Establish a LinkedIn Profile - Immediately make your business skills and experience available for the world to see and build your contacts network. This is not an online resume. This is a networking, promotion tool. For each position (paid or volunteer), briefly summarize your skills and responsibilities. Your profile gives your connections and browsing HR folk talking points to spur that next recommendation or job interview query. Write recommendations for your contacts; they may reciprocate. Update your status weekly. The update appears on everyone else's pages (keeping you fresh in their minds), gives an idea of your business skills and shows activity on your part. As you broaden your online business brand, maximize your exposure by linking to your blog, Twitter and any other online resources. LinkedIn's About is a great starting point.

2. Set Up a Twitter Account for You, The Professional - This is the account where you follow your industry thought leaders, talk with other business professionals, and start building a network in your desired field. Tapping into the Twitter stream of consciousness reveals what these industry professionals are working on, what skills you may need to develop, and how your unique abilities can help solve those challenges. Use an aggregator (like TweetDeck) to manage the wealth of streaming information, and follow Chris Brogan's advice on managing your time.

3. Write Your Resume - This is third because the simplicity, impact and immediacy of the first two rank them higher. Remember, your resume must answer not only the What, but also the So What. Sure you held this position with these responsibilities for this organization---what impact did you have by being there: positive increase, positive decrease, reduced time, improved relationships? Use numbers; 99% of the time.

4. Print Business Cards - Yes, get a card reader/sender for your phone (like Mashable's list), but you also need a hard copy version to fill the gap until we reach the same smart phone saturation point email achieved in replacing hard copy memos and letters. Don't short-change your printed business card with only contact information. Include three bullet points with three-word or less statements of your top marketable skills. Be unique in your list. Your Twitter stream listening post should give you which of your differentiator skills would catch someone's eye. You may also want to include your Twitter account and blog.

5. 10-second Response - Write down and practice saying a 10-second synopsis of who you are, what position you're seeking, and how you're using your three differentiators in whatever you've done recently. You will use some version of this response more frequently than you might expect.

6. Start a Microblog - You have great thoughts. You are the only one with your life experience and, therefore, your perspective in your industry. Writing your thoughts down builds your own understanding of your perspective and gives others the opportunity to expand your thinking. It's also another way employers can learn more about you and encourage a job contact. Simple tools like Posterous and WordPress make it easy to post content and distribute across multiple social media.

7. Network in Person - Join an organization with other professionals and build those personal relationships. Make it easy for your contacts to remember you and recommend you to others by defining yourself using your 10-second Response. Once you've built a relationship, ask if you can connect on LinkedIn. Twitter is a more open network and enables a connection without necessarily developing a relationship first. Larger metro areas often have a Young Professionals group, like this one in DC.

8. Volunteer - Take your focus off yourself and give of your business talents or personal abilities to a nonprofit organization. You'll help make the world a better place, and just might build your career skills and form beneficial relationships in the process. Seek out your favorite charity or check with your local United Way for a list of area nonprofits.

9. Above All and More Than Anything Else - Be yourself, be honest and be optimistic.

What else would you add to help a 20-something find her next marvelous career?

Filed under  //  social media  

Comments (1)