Wi-Fi Bandit Caught Again
This saga begins with me standing at a Starbucks counter repeating in an incredulous voice what the server had just told me, “The Wi-Fi isn’t free? I have to buy a Starbucks card first?” Nodding sympathetically with a wry smile, she agreed and then said in a conspiratorial whisper, “But it’s free down the street at Panera Bread.”
I was in the midst of a 238-mile journey home on a Friday night at 8:20 PM with a pending online task to complete, but I left.
I was willing to pay for coffee, and maybe a pastry, and possibly something else … but I was not going to pay for Wi-Fi. It’s like having to pay for napkins: “Napkins available for free with your $15 Starbucks card purchase.”
I drove down the street to Panera Bread, parked, shouldered my laptop case and hurried to the entrance. A colorful sign on the glass entry door caught my eye, “Free Wi-fi.” I bought coffee and a chocolate pastry, and began working. Just before the 9 PM closing time, I completed and emailed the revised file to my coworker across the country.
From the customer experience perspective, Panera Bread's free Wi-Fi was a true customer benefit: easy, free, non-intrusive. Starbucks' misguided attempt to force customer "loyalty" and stickiness derailed a potential customer into the welcoming arms of a competitor. I used to think, "Coffee = Starbucks." But now I've been taught, "Coffee = Panera Bread (+ Wi-Fi + food)." For a company centered on serving coffee, Starbucks now has nothing left in the equation to draw me in the doors again.
A few days later, I was traveling again and needed some coffee. I drove into a shopping center, past Starbucks and into an open parking space in front of Panera Bread. Shouldering my laptop case, I pushed in past the cheerful “Free Wi-Fi” sign on the door, ordered a coffee, a pastry and a sourdough soup bowl lunch, and clicked through the latest online commentary as I ate.
Caught again.



